Orillia, Ontario – Auto Insurance Guide

In less than 5 minutes find out if you’re overpaying for car insurance by comparing quotes from 30+ insurance providers.

The best part? It’s FREE

Orillia is located on Lake Simcoe, about 35 minutes from Barrie, Ontario. It is known as the Sunshine City and it has a population of around 30,000 residents. Orillia Transit oversees the city’s bus service, which runs every day of the week except Sundays. All of the buses depart from the downtown bus station, and run in large loops throughout the city.

Another popular way to get around Orillia is by car. If you own a vehicle and you live in Orillia then you’re going to need auto insurance. Use the following guide to help you find a car insurance broker in this Southern Ontario city.

Ron Johnston Insurance

Ron Johnston Insurance is a member of the Insurance Brokers Association of Ontario, which is a 12,000-member group comprised of insurance brokers in the province. The company is also a member of the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO). They have been offering auto insurance to people living in the community of Orillia since 1977. Their team is made up of Doug Johnston, Dean Johnston, Ron Johnston, Kathy Greig, and 13 other employees. Ron Johnston Insurance works with some of Canada’s top insurance companies such as Gore Mutual, Kingsway Insurance, Lombard Canada, and Wawanesa Insurance. You can get in touch with a representative from Ron Johnston Insurance by calling 705-325-6200 or by visiting their brokerage at 448 West Street North in Orillia.

McLean & Dickey Insurance

Located at 390 Laclie Street in Orillia, McLean & Dickey Insurance is another option for your home, cottage, farm, business, marine, and auto insurance needs. McLean & Dickey Insurance dates back to 1923, when George McLean Sr. began selling insurance in Orillia. There are now more than 30 people working for the company, and they provide a full line up of insurance products. Contact McLean & Dickey at 1-877-525-4461 or visit their location on Laclie Street.


CAA Orillia is located at 865 West Ridge Boulevard in Orillia. They are open between 9:00AM and 6:00PM from Monday to Friday, and on Saturdays from 9:30AM until 4:30PM. If you’re interested in purchasing auto insurance then you can call Helen Peters at 705-329-2758, or contact Leslie Messenger at 705-329-2934. CAA Orillia is a part of CAA South Central Ontario.

Will Marshall Insurance Brokers Ltd.

There are two Will Marshall Insurance locations in Ontario. One is located in Barrie and the other is located at 575 West Street South (Unit #8) in Orillia, Ontario. Will Marshall began selling insurance in 1983 when he formed a partnership with his brother and became a registered insurance broker so that he could serve the Orilia region. You can contact the Orillia branch by calling 705-326-5664 or visit their office to get quotes and find out more about the products that they sell.

G.B. Cragg Insurance

G.B. Cragg Insurance Brokers Limited is located at 3230 Monarch Drive in Orillia and they are open Monday to Friday between 8:30AM and 5:00PM. The company was founded in 1953 and they offer home insurance, business insurance, life insurance, and auto insurance from their offices in Orillia. You can get in touch with G.B. Cragg Insurance by calling 1-888-325-1393.

Recent Articles