Sarnia, Ontario Car Insurance

In less than 5 minutes find out if you’re overpaying for car insurance by comparing quotes from 30+ insurance providers.

The best part? It’s FREE

Sarnia is tucked away in Southwestern Ontario. The city has a population of more than 85,000. Public transportation in Sarnia is provided by Sarnia Transit, including charter service, transportation for events, transportation for people with disabilities, and traditional bus services within the City of Sarnia. There is a twice-daily train service to and from Toronto, Ontario.

A lot of people in Sarnia drive cars, trucks, vans, and SUVs. If you own a car in Ontario then you need to purchase the mandatory insurance coverage through one of the private insurance companies in the province. Luckily there are a number of insurance agents and brokers within the City of Sarnia. We’ve compiled a comprehensive list of those insurance providers to make the process that much easier for you.

Callister Musico Insurance

The Callister Musico Insurance Group is located at 1315 Michigan Avenue in Sarnia at the Trailside Commercial Centre. You can reach their offices at 519-332-2061. If you need to make an after-hours claim then call 519-332-2061. Callister Musico allows you to pay for your auto insurance by using TelPay. This service is free and is a simple online payment method. You need to sign up for a free TelPay account to take part in this payment program though. You can purchase car insurance for personal use and for commercial use from Callister Musico Insurance. They are affiliated with Aviva Pilot Insurance and The Economical Mutual Insurance Group.

Gamble Insurance

There are eight Gamble Insurance locations in Ontario. The Sarnia branch is located at 265 Exmouth Street and you can reach them on the telephone by calling 519-332-0480. The insurance brokers at Gamble Insurance are Shelley Sim, David Rusland, Shirley Swirsky, Mary Ann Russell, Gina Brown, and Gayle Jackson. The hours of operation for the Sarnia office are Monday to Friday between 9:00AM and 5:00PM. To learn more about their personal auto insurance policies please visit the Gamble Insurance website.

City Insurance

City Insurance & Financial Services has two offices in Ontario. The Sarnia office is located at 1270 Pontiac Court and the Petrolia office is located at 4110 Petrolia Line in Petrolia, Ontario. Both offices are open between 9:00AM and 5:00PM from Monday to Friday. The toll free number for both locations is 1-800-265-7588. City Insurance offers car insurance, motorcycle insurance, RV insurance, and motor home insurance. They have coverage for just about any vehicle, including commercial cars and trucks. You can get a free insurance quote by visiting the City Insurance website.

Magermans & Raes Insurance Brokers

Magermans & Raes Insurance has one branch in Sarnia and one in Petrolia, Ontario. The Sarnia Office is located at 774 London Road. They have two telephone numbers: 519-336-4620 and 1-800-268-4857. You can call either of those numbers to get auto insurance quotes from Magermans & Raes Insurance. They also sell life insurance, business insurance, and personal insurance.

CAA Sarnia

The Canadian Automobile Association (CAA) location in Sarnia can be found at 1095 London Road. To speak to Sandra Capp in the Insurance Department you can call 519-332-8592. To learn about CAA memberships or other CAA products call the toll free phone number 1-800-992-8143. The CAA Sarnia office is open from Monday to Friday between the hours of 9:00AM and 6:00PM. They are also open on Saturdays between 10:00AM and 1:00PM.

State Farm

There are six State Farm Insurance agents in Sarnia, Ontario: Gisele Bonin-Savage, Ernie Bonin, Louise Dottori, Jim Keys, Scott Trinder, and Chad Dreise. Almost all of their offices are open between 9:00AM and 5:00PM from Monday to Friday. Visit the State Farm Insurance website to learn more about their auto insurance policies.

Allstate Insurance

The Allstate Sarnia Branch is located at Unit 2 – 1440 Quinn Drive. If you want to get an insurance quote from Allstate then visit their offices from Monday to Friday or call them at 519-479-9995.

The Co-operators

There are three Co-operators Insurance agents located in and around Sarnia. Those three agents are Fabien Jagoo, Franco Filia, and Marianne Hope.

Recent Articles